Dear Joely: I Punished My Daughter for Sending Nudes. Then She Found My Video.

She reacted to her daughter’s humiliation with fury and punishment. Then her unlocked phone delivered a brutal lesson in empathy.

New
here?

Dear Joely,

I live in the south-west of England. I have a daughter (14) whose sending of ‘nudes’ to her one-time boyfriend was exposed at school in the most unpleasant way.

She found out the hard way that (a) the male of the species is not always to be trusted and (b) there are consequences for her actions.

I wish I could say that I was understanding and supportive when I found out about this (by being summoned to the headteacher's office), but my first reaction was judgmental and punitive. I grounded her for two weeks and confiscated her phone.

Obviously this meant that we were at each other's throats for days and that she had to deal, not only with the mortification and heartbreak of her situation, but with her banshee of a mother.

I am embarrassed by how I handled it and wish I could press rewind.

This next bit, I actually find hard to write and am only doing so because I am in bits, because you guarantee anonymity and because I genuinely need direction.

I have been dating now and then on the apps over the past year or so. I've had some fun times but mostly, I find it very disappointing.

A few weeks ago, I 'met' a man through a phone app. There was something I found very attractive about him and after a short back and forth, our messages got saucier. Before long we were sexting.

I found it fun and a bit of a turn-on.

One day my daughter was asking me why I hadn't commented on a link she'd sent me about something or another. I yelled out from the next room that I hadn't received it.

She picked up my phone from the bench, which was unlocked because I was playing music from it, and next thing, she's into my WhatsApp account, which is where I'd been chatting to the guy I mentioned.

I had sent him a short video in which I was naked, but worse, I was doing something he had asked me to do - I won't go into details but let's just say it was very much adult content.

Next thing, my daughter is in the doorway playing the video, the volume switched up to max. She stared at me and just said in a really cold voice "Nice, Mum. Really nice."

I could have died. I literally didn't have words. I took the phone from her, I'm sure I went as red as a beetroot, went into my room, locked the door and cried for several hours.

It's now the next day and I had to call in sick for work. I realise I'm the worst mother on the planet and I don't know what to do.

Yours,
Hypocrite doesn't begin to cover it

Dear Hypocrite Doesn’t Begin to Cover It,

First, you are not the worst mother on the planet. You are a frightened, mortified mother who reacted badly to her daughter’s crisis, then discovered, with almost theatrical precision, how easy it is to do the very thing you condemned.

That does not make your daughter’s situation and yours identical. She is fourteen. Her image was shared by someone she trusted, and she is dealing with the cruelty, humiliation and possible wider circulation of intimate material while still a child. Your video was made and sent as an adult, by choice, to another adult.

But it does mean you now understand something you did not understand in the headteacher’s office: intelligence, dignity and good judgement do not make anyone immune to desire, trust, impulsiveness or the belief that a private moment will remain private.

So go to your daughter.

Do not begin with an explanation of why your case is different. Do not make her comfort you. Do not ask her to pretend she did not see it.

Say something like:

“I am deeply embarrassed by what you saw, but I am more sorry for how I treated you. I reacted from fear and anger when you were already hurt and humiliated. I punished you when what you needed first was safety and support. I understand that now in a way I did not yesterday. I am sorry.”

Then listen.

She may be furious. She may laugh. She may say something designed to make you want to crawl under the floorboards. You will have to survive that without reaching for authority as a shield.

After that, deal with the practical part of her situation. Find out whether her images have been shared further, whether she is being bullied or threatened, and whether the school’s safeguarding lead is supporting her properly. In the UK, Childline’s Report Remove service can help young people under eighteen report sexual images of themselves online and seek their removal. If she is being threatened or made to feel unsafe, CEOP also accepts reports from young people and parents.

And yes, talk about phones, privacy and intimate images. But this time, have the conversation as two human beings who have both discovered that a glowing rectangle can turn private desire into public catastrophe with appalling speed.

You are not disqualified from motherhood because your daughter saw evidence that you are also a sexual adult. You are being offered something much more uncomfortable and useful: the chance to replace judgement with honesty.

Pressing rewind is unavailable.

Repair is not.

Yours, in second chances and considerably stronger passwords,
Joely